The 2024 United Kingdom Election – Did Tactical Voting Kick the Tories Out?
The Labour Party, led by Sir Keir Starmer, achieved a decisive victory in the United Kingdom’s general election earlier this month. Its majority in the House of Commons is the largest won by any government since 1997. The election, held on July 4, 2024, resulted in a significant change of government, with the ruling Conservative Party experiencing its worst result ever, securing only 24 percent of the vote and 121 seats.
Underneath this dramatic change were multiple shifts in voting patterns, magnified or suppressed by the electoral system. Although Labour had maintained a significant lead in opinion polls since late 2022, both Labour and the Conservatives saw their support drop during the campaign. Labour finished ten percent above the Conservatives in vote share, which was much less than what the polls had predicted. However, Labour’s vote was highly efficient, leading to a landslide of 411 seats (plus the Speaker) on only 34 percent of the vote, creating record disproportionality.
The combined vote share of the two main parties, at 57.4 percent, was the lowest since Labour became the main opposition to the Conservatives in the 1920s. Voter turnout was also down compared to the last election, meaning Labour won with the support of only about 21 percent of the electorate.
The Impact of Tactical Voting
The 2024 election was marked by a high degree of tactical voting, particularly by opposition voters in Conservative-held seats. Tactical voting played a crucial role in Labour’s victory and the Liberal Democrats’ significant gains.
Labour’s success was facilitated by its strategic move toward the political center, its non-threatening campaign promises, and a clear stance not to rejoin the European Union. In contrast, the Conservative Party suffered from internal scandals, economic underperformance, and a lack of public confidence in their leadership.
Key Contributing Factors:
- Economic Issues: The sluggish economy and underperforming health system were significant factors against the Conservatives.
- Scandals: Incidents such as “Partygate” and MPs betting on election outcomes damaged the party's credibility.
- Leadership Instability: The Conservatives were on their fifth prime minister since the Brexit referendum, contributing to voter dissatisfaction.
- Nigel Farage and Reform UK: The rise of Reform UK under Nigel Farage further split the right-wing vote, causing significant losses for the Conservatives.
Regional Dynamics
- Scotland: Labour made substantial gains, winning 37 of the 57 seats, largely due to the problems and scandals within the Scottish National Party.
- England and Wales: Labour’s vote share in Wales dropped slightly, while in England, Labour’s overall vote changed little but managed to reclaim the "red wall" seats primarily due to Conservative losses to Reform UK.
The Labour Party's victory was a result of both strategic positioning and the inefficiencies within the Conservative Party. Tactical voting was a significant factor but not the sole reason for the Conservative defeat. The division of the right-wing vote between the Conservatives and Reform UK played a larger role in the outcome. Moving forward, the Conservatives will need to address this division and re-evaluate their strategies to regain voter trust and cohesion within the party.
The 2024 election has set a precedent for future electoral strategies, highlighting the impact of tactical voting and the importance of addressing internal party issues and voter concerns.